Chalk Paint vs. Milk Paint and the One I Prefer

I remember the first time I purchased chalk paint. I was in a little boutique about 30 miles north of where I lived. I kept staring at all the furniture painted with this new “chalk paint” style and I had to try it. My thoughts were “wow, am I really going to pay Forty dollars for a quart of paint?”  And what would I paint? All I knew was that I loved this style and I had to try it and share all about my thoughts on Chalk paint vs. Milk paint.

chalk paint vs. milk paint

This was the beginning of my furniture painting journey.

Let me share one more thing about my trip to that little boutique.  While I was perusing the isles of painted furniture, I found a really neat vintage chair.  The owner had apparently repainted it with white chalk paint and recovered it with a scripted fabric.

chalk painted chair

I loved the vintage style and farmhouse look of it. The ironic thing was that the chair was $42, and the chalk paint that I was about to buy was $40.

The owner then asked if I wanted to take her class on “how to chalk paint” for $50. I decided I would buy the chair and the chalk paint and study how she applied to chalk paint to the chair. Was this cheating? Maybe? But I had a limited amount to spend and I wanted that chair šŸ™‚

What’s up with Milk Paint and why do you use it?

After I’d been using chalk paint a few years I started hearing about a similar product called milk paint. I knew both paints were made of different ingredients, but both were still primarily used to paint furniture.  So which one do I like better? That’s a hard question.

Milk Painted TV Stand

Above is a before and after picture from my milk painted tv stand project.

Before I give you my opinion, I want to share some facts about chalk paint vs. milk paint and their differences.

Facts about Chalk Paint:

  • One of chalk paints biggest draws is that it does not require a primer because it will stick to almost any wood finish. In the furniture refinishing business this was huge. You could paint over polyurethane, wax, even glue and it would stick! Gone were the days of stripping and sanding and preparing wood for paint. 
  • Chalk paint distresses easily with a little sand paper. It comes off in a fine powder, which also makes it very forgiving.
  • Chalk paint is {mostly} made of latex paint, calcium carbonate and water. The calcium is what makes gives it the chalky finish.
  • Because chalk paint “dusts” off easily, I always recommend adding a top coat of wax or varnish.  Speaking from experience, the paint does not hold up well to without a top coat.
  • You can make your own chalk paint, but most people buy it already mixed in a quart size can.
  • You can mix chalk paint colors easily. The paint can also be diluted for a smoother finish or for use in a paint sprayer.
  • A little chalk paint goes a long way. I was fearful when I purchased the $40 quart size can that I was wasting my money, but I covered about three full pieces of furniture with it!
  • For those of you who like the convenience of a spray paint, you can find chalky spray paint in any big name store.

Facts about Milk Paint:

  • Unlike Chalk paint, milk paint has been around for years. The ingredients are natural and eco friendly.
  • You will find milk paint {mostly} in the powdered form. All it requires is to be mixed with water.
  • The main ingredients for milk paint are quark (Quark is a type of fresh dairy product made by warming soured milk) and lime. The downside to these ingredients is the smell!
  • The powdered form of milk paint will require the addition of a bonding agent if you don’t want the “chippy” look.
  • Speaking of adding a bonding agent, this is the bonus for vintage lovers like myself. If you want the aged chippy wood look, all you have to do is apply milk paint without the boding agent and you will find that the paint will chip naturally over a period of just a few hours.
  • The downside to the powdered form of milk paint is that it can be rather tricky to mix the perfect consistency.  Most new furniture painters would rather buy milk paint in a ready to go can. There are a few brands that come already mixed like General Finishes milk paint.  unfortunately, with the “ready made” milk paint cans the bonding agent is already mixed in.
  • In my opinion, milk paint with the bonding agent does not always require a top coat. If the piece of furniture I’m working on doesn’t get a lot of wear and tear, I rarely use a top coat.
  • I have found that milk paint does show brush strokes much easier than chalk paint.
  • Milk paint does cost less than chalk paint, but one can of milk paint does not cover near as many projects as chalk paint. So then the question is, does milk paint really cost less? I’m still undecided on this one.

Which one do I prefer? Chalk paint vs. Milk paint?

I love the smooth finish of milk paint and the fact that I can create that chippy look by forgoing the bonding agent. I even used milk paint to paint my kitchen cabinets. 

On the downside, milk paint does show brush strokes easier than chalk paint and does not bond as well (in my opinion).

Back to the question, which paint do I prefer? It depends on what I’m painting.

I do prefer applying chalk paint to a furniture piece that has many layers of old paint or varnish.

It will give a better coverage and more “even toned” look. The only downside is that it will require a good wax or top coat.

chalk painted kitchen table

The kitchen table above was a chalk paint project that I’m still super pleased with.

Milk paint is my go-to paint for that chippy look. Otherwise, I prefer using chalk paint because of it’s better coverage and ability to hide most brush strokes.

chippy paint technique

A close look at the chippy paint technique that I applied to this vintage fireplace mantel with milk paint.

Disclosure: this is my opinion and some of you might disagree. I’ve tried to lay out all the facts first and then form my opinion to give you guys a good knowledge base about chalk paint vs milk paint.

I hope my thoughts about chalk paint vs. milk paint help you figure out what paint to use to repurpose or up cycle something of your own!

Feel free to drop a note below if you have any comments or questions about a project or furniture piece.

If you enjoyed this post and want to save it for later I would love for you to pin it to Pinterest {Here}.

You also might be interested in my post about Paint vs. Primer. 

how to use chalk paint


50 thoughts on “Chalk Paint vs. Milk Paint and the One I Prefer

  1. Thank you for sharing your insights and opinions on these 2 kinds of furniture paint. I have been doing quite a bit of reading about this and will add this information to my ‘file’. A local thrift/furniture store offers Annie Sloan classes for $75. Like you, I decided to do my own research!!

  2. Thanks for answering so many questions I already had about milk paint. I have used chalk paint for years but have yet to find something I wanted to try milk paint with. Now I will be on the lookout for something new. Visiting from Over the Moon party.

  3. this was very interesting. I have painted a few pieces of furniture, but always prime and use regular paint. I have been wondering about chalk and milk paint and now I know about them. I am thinking the chalk paint would be my choice.

  4. Very interesting. I don’t paint a lot, but if I did I think I would tend towards chalk paint, just because I don’t have the patience for sanding…
    Thank you for sharing at The Really Crafty Link Party this week. Pinned!

  5. Thanks for this very informative post about the differences between milk and chalk paint. I knew they were different, but wasn’t sure how they were different. Back in the 90’s, I used milk paint to get that chalky vintage look on a sofa table I had bought. However, I wasn’t very pleased with the coverage. As you indicated, it was streaky, and even with waxing, I felt the finish wasn’t stable. Recently, I tried chalk paint for the first time and I really loved it –no prep, even coverage, and after waxing it seems like it will hold up well. I have come to the conclusion that chalk paint is probably a better product for less experienced painters, as it is more forgiving.

  6. I have never seen or heard of milk paint before but love the sound of it! I have used chalk paint loads and love that it will stick to anything so projects are quick and easier. Thanks for sharing. Iā€™m going to go and look up milk paint now! #thatfridaylinky

  7. Sadly, my experiences painting furniture with chalk paint were a bust. I got great results for small projects, but the one piece of furniture I tried peeled like nobody’s business. We’re talking large strips across the entire top. And that was after deglossing twice and applying a topcoat. Definitely frustrating. Oh well, I’m not much of a furniture painter anyway! šŸ˜€ Thanks for sharing your experiences with both. I look forward to giving milk paint a try sometime too. And thanks for sharing at the #happynowlinkup!

    1. oh wow, I’m so sorry you had a bad experience with chalk paint. May I ask what type of paint you used? I’ve tried the chalk paint from walmart and it was pretty sorry. But the Annie Sloan chalk paint works wonders.

  8. Thanks! I make my own chalk paint but have never bought any so I have nothing to compare it to. Have you ever made it? Also, I have a small dresser I am rehabbing into a bathroom vanity. I was thinking about doing a dry brush effect. Do you have a recommendation for a type of paint I should use? @cottage market

    1. Hi Terri,
      I have never made chalk paint. As silly as it sounds I’m always afraid it won’t ever turn out near as great as something store bought. As far as the dry brush effect, I’ve used multiple paints for that and I can’t say that I like one more than the other. I would make sure to use a chip brush….I’ve found that the type of brush you use might matter just as much or more than the paint. You probably already know that though. I’m a fan of chalk paint for any sort of dry brush effect, but it might be because I prefer chalk paint period. šŸ™‚

  9. I love both types Lindsey, it depends on the look I’m going for and the style of the piece I’m painting as to which I prefer, I love them both for different reasons. I find that true milkpaint does not always need a bonding agent to prevent chipping. It depends on the finish if any, that you are painting over. But, It certainly is a bit more temperamental than Chalky paint which gives more consistent results over many types of finishes for sure. Thanks for sharing your experience with the two types at #fridaysfurniturefix always a pleasure havin you!

  10. Have you found any top coats for chalk paint that are low/no VOC and nontoxic (and don’t cause the yellowing issue)? I know a lot of people use poly, but I hate the idea of anything that toxic off-gassing where I prep food (I chalk painted a ceramic tile backsplash). The few nontoxic options I have found specifically call out not being able to bond to chalk paint.

  11. The one lovely thing you forgot to mention is the feel of a waxed piece of chalk painted furniture! It feels velvety. I adore Annie’s paint! I read years ago that you can’t remove milk easily, once painted. That you have to use ammonia to remove it. Our early American ancestors made this paint and it is still hanging on to many pieces. I have yet to use it. I think the best site is Miss Mustard Seed, she has how to info for this.
    Thanjs for your info, loved it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.